SSubida Skills

Esc to close · results from all notes, skills and people

Marketing›Ecommerce & DTC

Creative economics — the median ad loses money, so cut the cost per ad (CTC's 1.3M-ad study)

CTC's analysis of 1.339M Meta ads across 158 brands — the median ad is worth −$3.20 in 60-day contribution, the average +$507, and the top 5% of ads produce 73% of all value — so you can't change the odds, only the price of each "ticket"; commission-only creator programs (Tribe, Refunnel) that pay only for winners let The Normal Brand triple ad volume and double spend at the same incremental ROAS.

Updated 2026-10-24·2 sources·creative-volumecreative-economicsmeta-adsugccreator-programswhitelistingincrementalityecommerce

Creative economics: the median ad loses money, so cut the cost per ad

TL;DR

  • Score each ad by 60-day contribution: conversion value × incrementality factor × 60-day LTV × gross margin − ad spend.
  • Across 1.339M ads (158 brands, 2 years): the median ad is worth −$3.20, and this holds at 133 of 158 brands. The average is +$507, because value is extremely right-skewed.
  • Top 1% of ads = 41% of value. Next 4% = 32%. Top 5% = 73%. Meta caps the downside by starving losers for free.
  • Taylor Holiday says no brand he’s seen can reliably change these odds. What you control is the cost of each “ticket”. At ~$300 an ad and one $10K winner per ~80 launches, paid-up-front production doesn’t pencil.
  • Invert the creative cash cycle: commission-only creator programs (Tribe, Refunnel, TikTok Shop affiliates) mean you pay only when an ad sells.
  • The Normal Brand: ~380 → ~1,200 new ads a month at zero production cost, spend +100–140% year on year at the same incremental ROAS. The median ad didn’t improve. Winners above $10K went from 5 to 16.

Details

The stuck brand. The Normal Brand (menswear, mediocre LTV) stalled in Q1 2026. CTC launched 1,199 ads in the quarter (400, 240, 524 by month), and every push for scale broke first-order profitability. Production cost rose with volume because every ad was paid up front.1 On the 60-day contribution metric, its median ad was worth about −$2 and its average $24. 85% of ads lost money, and the typical ad cost more than $24 to make.23

The 1.3M-ad study. The median ad was −$3.20 (negative at 133 of 158 brands) and the average ~$507. Of the ads, 631K lost money, 246K made money and 11K made “big money”.45 Meta “kills your losers for free”: spend on losers is capped, while upside is unbounded.6 The top 1% of ads produced 41% of value and the next 4% another 32%.7 Taylor’s claim is that you can’t alter the odds of this lottery, only the price of the ticket. Creative production cost is “the hidden number destroying your ad economics”.89

The ticket-price maths. Assume one $10K winner per ~80 launches and ~$300 per video ad. Taylor puts the cost per winner at ~$26,400, so “it doesn’t pencil”.10 The fix is to make the channel that produces the asset carry its cost, like consignment.1112

  • Old cycle: pay for production → pay Meta → maybe get cash back 90 days later.
  • Inverted cycle: seed product → creator submits a video → you whitelist it as a Meta ad → it sells → you pay the creator a commission on attributed sales.12

He expects the arbitrage to fade as creators demand a “terminal price of creative” that shares the risk fairly.13

The Normal Brand after switching to Tribe (Apr–Jun 2026).

  • Spend rose +126%, +140% and +100% year on year in April, May and June, at the same ROAS and the same incremental ROAS.1415
  • New ads went from ~380 to ~1,200 a month. In June, Tribe ads were 78% of live ads and 81.5% of spend.1415
  • The average ad became 5.4x more profitable but still under $300. The economics only work because production cost went to zero.16
  • Median 60-day spend per ad didn’t move ($920 → $1,053 → $924 for Tribe ads), but the 99th percentile rose from $3,300 to $6,800. Ads clearing $10K went from 5 to 16, and Tribe made 12 of them.161718
  • His conclusion: “the ceiling wasn’t demand, it was creative supply”. Hold your quality bar constant and scale volume against it.1518

Curated creator networks (Joy Sharma, CTC). Refunnel had one-click whitelisting via Meta’s API and ~50,000 whitelisted creators. CTC asked it to pull every creator more than one standard deviation above the mean (~3,000 people) into a community. It offers flat fees rather than a percentage of spend or revenue, and it handles tax forms (1099s) that DIY creator programs pile up.192021 (Offered free to CTC clients, which is a commercial tie.)

Disagreements / caveats

See also

Footnotes

  1. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 16:55 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  2. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 17:42 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  3. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 18:29 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  4. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 19:15 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  5. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 20:01 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  6. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 20:53 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  7. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 21:43 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  8. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 22:32 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  9. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 23:22 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  10. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 24:11 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  11. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 24:57 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  12. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 25:44 — Taylor Holiday ↩ ↩2

  13. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 26:33 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  14. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 27:19 — Taylor Holiday ↩ ↩2

  15. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 28:09 — Taylor Holiday ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  16. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 28:57 — Taylor Holiday ↩ ↩2

  17. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 29:44 — Taylor Holiday ↩

  18. Low LTV Doesn’t Have to Limit Your Ecommerce Growth @ 30:30 — Taylor Holiday ↩ ↩2

  19. Ecommerce Growth With a Money-Back Guarantee @ 20:32 — Joy Sharma ↩

  20. Ecommerce Growth With a Money-Back Guarantee @ 21:17 — Joy Sharma ↩

  21. Ecommerce Growth With a Money-Back Guarantee @ 22:03 — Joy Sharma ↩