SSubida Skills

Esc to close · results from all notes, skills and people

Marketing›Ecommerce & DTC

Finding and recruiting UGC creators for ecommerce ads

How the Smart Marketer agency sources UGC creators for paid ads at scale — a creator "roster" built like a portfolio, a "creative menu" of formats, direct hires vs JoinBrands vs TikTok Shop, nano-tier targeting, email outreach with a stated $150–400 rate and >90% response.

Updated 2026-10-24·1 source·ecommerceugccreatorscreative-operationspaid-socialmeta-ads

Finding and recruiting UGC creators for ecommerce ads

TL;DR

  • Treat creators as paid-ad talent, not influencers: you want raw footage to cut into many ads, so follower count matters little.1
  • Build a roster like an investment portfolio — creators from different niches, backgrounds and styles to reach different audience pockets.2
  • Keep a “creative menu” of formats (scripted, unscripted testimonial, hook-only, static, animation) so one angle can be shot in many styles.3
  • Source by direct hire (search Instagram/TikTok/Facebook by niche keywords) when you need raw files; use JoinBrands to move fast; TikTok Shop creators post to their own channels and may not hand over footage.45
  • Target nano creators (<10K followers): cheaper, hungry, more yeses.6
  • Outreach by email (from the bio/portfolio), not DMs: intro, brand + product link, the actual pay rate. Melvin gets replies >90% of the time.78

Details

Who. Melvin Cotton III, creative operations manager at the Smart Marketer agency, interviewed by Molly Pittman (Aug 2026). His role — connecting strategists, editors, creators and clients — is one Molly says most teams lack; most of creative production is logistics.9

The system. Sourcing → vetting → brief (structure and content type) → asset management organised by hook, product and offer → performance feedback that informs the next brief.10

Creative menu. Categories include video-style assets (AI animation, GIFs, graphic videos), statics (carousels, graphic posts) and creator content: hook-focused (creator records supplied hooks), unscripted (testimonial-style ramble), fully scripted (verbatim). Pick the style per hypothesis from your research; the same hook/angle can then be produced across many formats for volume.3

Where to find them.45

  • Direct hires (Smart Marketer’s default): search platforms with niche keywords (“dog products”, “leggings”), browse portfolios. Slow, but full control and raw files. They are building AI scraping to speed this up.
  • Creator platforms (e.g. JoinBrands): browse a list, scale quickly — but you may only get the final edit, not raw files. Good early; outgrow it once you iterate on footage.
  • TikTok Shop: send product + timeline; creators post on their own channels; footage access varies.

Tiers (as Melvin defines them): mega 1M+, macro ~50–100K, micro ~10–20K+, nano <10K. He mostly targets nano — good creators just starting out, reasonable fees, sometimes open to trade deals.6

Outreach email. Introduce yourself and the agency/brand, link the product, state a concrete pay rate (he benchmarks against SAG/industry rates: typically $150–300, up to ~$400 for very experienced creators). DMs look less legitimate; he used one only for a seasoned creator, still with website and product links.7 In 3.5 years he recalls only 2–3 projects with no response at all.8

Disagreements / caveats

  • This is a paid-ad footage model (one-off fee, edited in-house). App-focused organic programs pay per post with view bonuses — see How to find, vet and pay UGC creators for an app (Nicole Cheung’s $10–30 base + CPM bonuses). Different goal, different economics.
  • The >90% response rate comes from a trusted agency face with clear terms; brands cold-emailing may see less.

See also

Footnotes

  1. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 36:41 — Molly Pittman ↩

  2. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 18:46 — Melvin Cotton III ↩

  3. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 20:20 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  4. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 22:46 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  5. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 25:14 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  6. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 35:09 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  7. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 29:29 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  8. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 34:15 — Melvin Cotton III ↩ ↩2

  9. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 04:27 — Molly Pittman ↩

  10. How We Work With UGC Creators at Scale: From Finding Them to Contracts and More | SM Podcast Ep 287 @ 17:59 — Melvin Cotton III ↩